How to Evaluate the Thermal Fade Stability of Automotive Brake Pads: A Friction Coefficient and Thickness Wear Test Comparison

Back

Automotive Brake Pads | Friction Material Technology

How to Evaluate the Thermal Fade Stability of Automotive Brake Pads: A Friction Coefficient and Thickness Wear Test Comparison

When a braking system is exposed to sustained heat loads, whether the friction material can maintain adequate friction matters more than the friction coefficient of any single stop. ADUI compared its R&D material with a commercial reference material across two thermal fade stages, examining stop-by-stop friction coefficient behavior and brake pad thickness wear after testing.

1st Thermal Fade | Maximum Relative Drop

13.7%/38.5%

ADUI R&D material / Commercial reference material

Calculated from the mean friction coefficient of stop 1 in this stage to the subsequent minimum. A descriptive calculation used in this article, not a standardized rating.

1st Thermal Fade | Lowest Mean Friction Coefficient per Stop

0.272/0.193

ADUI R&D material / Commercial reference material

Friction coefficient μ (dimensionless). The lowest per-stop mean friction level of each material during this fade stage.

Relative Difference in Thickness Wear

-77.5%

R&D material 0.53 mm / Reference material 2.36 mm

Relative difference in thickness wear in this bench test only; not equivalent to real-vehicle pad life.

Each material was tested once, on different dates. Results apply only to the specified bench procedure; see the end of the article for full limitations.

Test Conditions and Limitations
Item ADUI R&D material Commercial reference material
Test equipment NT15 friction material inertia scale dynamometer
Procedure designation S26867 (report states ISO 26867 test procedure)
Specimen area 1,000 mm²
Test inertia 0.89 kg·m²
Thermal fade stages 1st and 2nd thermal fade, 15 consecutive stops each
Test date 2026-11-02 2026-10-20
Ambient temperature 25.6°C approx. 30°C
Relative humidity 72% 65%
Number of reports One One
Chart data definition Mean friction coefficient per stop; all minimum values in this article refer to "the lowest of the per-stop mean friction coefficients"
Repeat tests, rotor material and surface condition, specimen batch To be confirmed

Note: The procedure designation indicates only the test method used; it does not mean the product is ISO certified. Test dates, ambient conditions and temperature history differ between the two tests and should be taken into account.

1. Why Does Friction Stability Matter During Thermal Fade?

During repeated braking, the temperature at the friction interface can rise continuously. As the heat load increases, the contact condition, surface film and friction characteristics of the material may change, causing the friction coefficient to drop or fluctuate. This loss of friction performance under high heat load is commonly called thermal fade.

When evaluating thermal fade, comparing the mean friction coefficient of a stage is not enough. It is also necessary to look at stop-by-stop changes across the stage, the lowest friction level reached, and the recovery behavior in later stops.

In this case study, two friction materials were compared under the same test procedure settings. The focus is on the two thermal fade stages rather than judging material performance by the initial friction coefficient alone.

2. First Thermal Fade: Smaller Friction Drop for the R&D Material

The first thermal fade stage consists of 15 consecutive stops. At stop 1, the mean friction coefficients of the two materials were 0.315 and 0.314, essentially the same level. Both then declined, but by different amounts.

The lowest per-stop mean friction coefficient recorded for the ADUI R&D material in this stage was 0.272, compared with 0.193 for the commercial reference material. Using each material's stop 1 mean friction coefficient as the baseline, the maximum relative drop to the subsequent minimum was approximately 13.7% and 38.5%, respectively.

In this first thermal fade stage, the ADUI R&D material therefore maintained a higher friction floor with a smaller drop. Both materials later showed a recovery in friction coefficient, indicating that behavior during heating is not a one-directional change.

Figure 1 | First Thermal Fade: Mean Friction Coefficient over 15 Stops

  • ADUI R&D material (circles)
  • Commercial reference material (squares)
  • Stop 1 baseline

← Swipe to view the full chart (stops 1 to 15) →

First thermal fade: mean friction coefficient over 15 stops, two-line chart X axis: stops 1 to 15. Y axis: mean friction coefficient per stop, μ, from 0 to 0.50. R&D material: stop 1 at 0.315, minimum 0.272 at stop 6, a relative drop of about 13.7%. Reference material: stop 1 at 0.314, minimum 0.193 at stop 9, a relative drop of about 38.5%. 0.000.050.100.150.200.250.300.350.400.450.50 123456789101112131415 Stop number (first thermal fade stage) Mean friction coefficient per stop, μ Stop 1: 0.315 / 0.314 -13.7% Min 0.272 -38.5% Min 0.193

Maximum relative drop:ADUI R&D material 0.315 → 0.272 (approx. 13.7%)Commercial reference material 0.314 → 0.193 (approx. 38.5%)

Stop-by-stop mean friction coefficient during the first thermal fade stage; this is not a continuous time-based curve. The 13.7% and 38.5% values are this case study's own "maximum drop relative to stop 1", calculated as (stop 1 value - minimum) / stop 1 value. They are not a standardized fade rate.
This chart shows friction coefficient changes by stop number. The end temperatures of the two materials at each stop were not identical, so this comparison mainly reflects friction behavior under the specified bench procedure, not a direct comparison under exactly the same temperature conditions.
Show full data for the 15 stops of the first thermal fade
Stop R&D mean μ Reference mean μ R&D end temp. (°C) Reference end temp. (°C)
1 0.315 0.314 279 298
2 0.315 0.272 363 385
3 0.299 0.252 437 424
4 0.302 0.240 478 464
5 0.285 0.229 515 490
6 0.272 0.211 554 488
7 0.273 0.205 565 539
8 0.277 0.194 562 546
9 0.295 0.193 587 572
10 0.311 0.194 595 571
11 0.317 0.208 626 619
12 0.334 0.263 646 605
13 0.370 0.318 635 627
14 0.367 0.330 659 649
15 0.384 0.352 674 646
15-stop mean 0.3144 0.2517 - -

Highlighted cells mark each material's lowest per-stop mean friction coefficient in this stage. End temperatures are provided for reference only.

3. Second Thermal Fade: Steadily Rising Friction for the R&D Material

In the second thermal fade test, the per-stop mean friction coefficient of the ADUI R&D material rose steadily from 0.304 to 0.448, with no sustained downward trend in the later stops.

The commercial reference material declined after reaching 0.401, indicating that the two materials have different friction characteristics under high heat load.

The stage mean friction coefficient of the ADUI R&D material in this test was 0.3787, higher than the 0.3584 of the commercial reference material.

Interpretation

A rising friction coefficient does not necessarily mean better overall stability; temperature changes, friction coefficient fluctuation and actual operating conditions must still be considered. In this stage the R&D material showed a wider stop-to-stop range, and the lowest per-stop mean friction coefficients of the two materials were close, at 0.304 and 0.306. It should therefore not be claimed that the R&D material shows smaller fluctuation in every thermal fade stage.

Figure 2 | Second Thermal Fade: Mean Friction Coefficient over 15 Stops

  • ADUI R&D material (circles)
  • Commercial reference material (squares)
  • Stage mean (15 stops)

← Swipe to view the full chart (stops 1 to 15) →

Second thermal fade: mean friction coefficient over 15 stops, two-line chart X axis: stops 1 to 15. Y axis: mean friction coefficient per stop, μ, from 0 to 0.50. R&D material rises from 0.304 to 0.448, stage mean 0.3787. Reference material ranges from 0.306 to 0.401, stage mean 0.3584. The R&D material shows a wider stop-to-stop range. 0.000.050.100.150.200.250.300.350.400.450.50 123456789101112131415 Stop number (second thermal fade stage) Mean friction coefficient per stop, μ Mean 0.3787 Mean 0.3584 Min 0.304 Min 0.306 Max 0.448 Max 0.401

Stop-to-stop range of mean values:ADUI R&D material 0.304-0.448 (range 0.144)Commercial reference material 0.306-0.401 (range 0.095)

Friction coefficient behavior of the two materials in the second thermal fade stage. The R&D material rose steadily from 0.304 to 0.448 and had the higher stage mean; its stop-to-stop variation was also larger. Expressed as the coefficient of variation of the 15 per-stop means, fluctuation was about 13.9% for the R&D material and about 7.4% for the reference material. This stage therefore reflects different friction characteristics, not superiority on every stability indicator.
This chart shows friction coefficient changes by stop number. The end temperatures of the two materials at each stop were not identical, so this comparison mainly reflects friction behavior under the specified bench procedure, not a direct comparison under exactly the same temperature conditions.
Show full data for the 15 stops of the second thermal fade
Stop R&D mean μ Reference mean μ R&D end temp. (°C) Reference end temp. (°C)
1 0.304 0.348 303 292
2 0.307 0.350 379 376
3 0.322 0.360 464 423
4 0.327 0.383 517 505
5 0.337 0.386 530 494
6 0.342 0.388 535 526
7 0.360 0.401 578 549
8 0.387 0.388 614 557
9 0.398 0.348 610 585
10 0.410 0.338 635 601
11 0.425 0.306 619 627
12 0.429 0.322 651 620
13 0.436 0.351 671 622
14 0.448 0.361 666 643
15 0.448 0.346 678 638
15-stop mean 0.3787 0.3584 - -

Highlighted cells mark each material's lowest per-stop mean friction coefficient in this stage. End temperatures are provided for reference only.

4. Thickness Wear: Lower Wear Depth for the R&D Material

Beyond friction performance under high heat load, brake pad thickness wear also influences material development and application requirements.

After testing, the thickness wear of the ADUI R&D material was 0.53 mm, compared with 2.36 mm for the commercial reference material. Using the reference material as the baseline, the R&D material's thickness wear was approximately 77.5% lower.

Figure 3 | Thickness Wear Comparison (mm)

  • ADUI R&D material
  • Commercial reference material
Thickness wear comparison chart ADUI R&D material 0.53 mm, commercial reference material 2.36 mm; 77.5% lower in this test. Y axis starts at 0. 0.00.51.01.52.02.5 Thickness wear (mm) 0.53 mm 2.36 mm -77.5% in this test ADUI R&Dmaterial Commercialreference Relative to the commercial reference material
Brake pad thickness wear after this bench test. Relative difference = (0.53 / 2.36 - 1) x 100% = approx. -77.5%. This does not represent a real-vehicle pad life improvement ratio.

5. Why Does Friction Behavior Change During Thermal Fade?

The high-temperature performance of friction materials is influenced by the binder system, fillers, fibers, abrasives and lubricants, as well as changes in friction contact conditions and surface films.

As brake temperature rises, different materials may show different degrees of friction coefficient drop, recovery or fluctuation. Manufacturers therefore need to evaluate friction level, minimum values and stop-to-stop changes under high heat load together, rather than relying on a single number.

However, these two reports alone cannot prove that the performance differences come from any specific formulation ingredient or manufacturing process. Confirming the cause would require material analysis, rotor surface inspection and repeat testing.

6. Conclusions and Directions for Evaluating Thermal Fade Stability

The test results show that in the first thermal fade stage, the ADUI R&D material had a smaller friction coefficient drop and maintained a higher lowest per-stop mean friction coefficient.

In the second thermal fade stage, its friction coefficient rose steadily, with no sustained downward trend observed in the later stops.

In addition, the thickness wear of the R&D material was 0.53 mm, lower than the 2.36 mm of the commercial reference material.

These results indicate that, in this specified bench test, the ADUI R&D material shows high-temperature friction behavior and low thickness wear characteristics that merit further validation.

When developing automotive brake pads, the following indicators are recommended for evaluation together:

  1. (1)Trend of the stop-by-stop mean friction coefficient during thermal fade stages.
  2. (2)Lowest per-stop mean friction coefficient during thermal fade stages.
  3. (3)Friction coefficient drop and recovery under consistent definitions.
  4. (4)Heat load conditions and measurement locations, including temperature changes.
  5. (5)Brake pad thickness wear after testing and rotor compatibility.
  6. (6)Consistency of results across batches and repeat tests.

For brand owners and braking system developers, what truly matters is not having the highest number on a single indicator, but whether a material can maintain friction performance that meets product requirements under the specified speed, pressure, temperature and wear conditions.

7. Frequently Asked Questions

Does a higher mean friction coefficient during thermal fade mean better stability?

Not necessarily. The mean friction coefficient reflects the overall friction level of a stage; stability also requires looking at stop-to-stop drop, minimum values and fluctuation. They are different indicators.

Why compare the lowest friction coefficient in the first thermal fade?

Because the stage mean alone can hide a significant drop during the process. The lowest per-stop mean friction coefficient shows the lowest friction level each material reached under this high heat load procedure.

Do the second thermal fade results prove the R&D material is more stable overall?

No. In this stage the R&D material's friction coefficient rose steadily and its stage mean was higher, but its stop-to-stop fluctuation was also larger. Each evaluation indicator should be interpreted separately.

Does 77.5% less thickness wear mean 77.5% longer pad life?

It cannot be converted directly. Actual pad life must be validated separately for the specific vehicle, braking system and operating conditions.

8. Test Data and Interpretation Limitations

Test reports: This case study compares two friction material inertia scale dynamometer reports, with only one report per material. The test equipment was an NT15 machine under procedure designation S26867, with the same specimen area of 1,000 mm² and test inertia of 0.89 kg·m².

Condition differences: The two reports differ in test date (2026-11-02 and 2026-10-20) and ambient conditions (25.6°C / 72% RH and approx. 30°C / 65% RH). The temperature history and end temperature of each stop were also not identical.

Test method: The reports state the ISO 26867 test procedure. This refers to the test method only and does not mean the product holds ISO certification. The 13.7% and 38.5% values for the first thermal fade are descriptive calculations defined in this article and do not represent a standardized ISO 26867 fade rating.

Data definition: The charts in Sections 2 and 3 use the mean friction coefficient of each of the 15 stops in the two thermal fade stages. Minimum values in this article are "the lowest of the per-stop mean friction coefficients", not the lowest instantaneous friction coefficient within a single stop; the two must not be mixed.

Scope: Results apply only to the specified test conditions and samples in this study. They cannot be used to directly infer real-vehicle pad life, production batch consistency or performance under all operating conditions. Noise, rotor wear and real-vehicle braking performance were not verified, and no repeat-test variation data is available.

0 Top